The repeated bomb blasts in Mumbai city have once again brought into sharp
focus the threat of mass casualty terrorism to kill innocent citizens.
As the terrorists find it more & more difficult to strike at visible
symbols of state power & security establishments, they are shifting
their attention to soft targets that are easier to hit. With virtually
endless supply of such soft targets and places of public congregations,
India faces the formidable challenge of countering terrorists who seem
to be motivated by a strong desire to vent their anger against the Indian
state. The threat of terrorist strikes at soft targets has added a new
dimension to terrorist violence because the ISI of Pakistan has established
its network of modules not only in Nepal and Bangladesh, but in many towns
and cities of India. The suspected role of educated youngsters recruited
by the Students Islamic Movement of India (SIMI) has made the battle against
terror even more difficult. Being educated, these youngsters quickly learn
how to make bombs, arrange safe houses, Communicate clandestinely &
transfer funds. This new breed of terrorists have made common cause with
the ‘Jehadis’ to punish the civil society for perceived injustice
meted out to fellow Muslims in India.
The serial blasts in Mumbai on 11th July, unlike the
blasts in 1993, left the investigative agencies clueless. There is no
doubt that months of preparation went behind the well-coordinated plot
which was meticulously planned and thoroughly rehearsed. The intelligence
agencies claim to have forewarned local authorities. But there was no
specific intelligence input as a result of which Mumbai police were caught
unawares. Such specific intelligence can be obtained either through interception
of communication or through a tip off from someone who has penetrated
a terrorist module. Terrorist strikes of such magnitude are planned and
financed by Pakistan-based outfits like the Lashkar-e-Toiba, but these
cannot be implemented without local support & well-trained local operatives.
The Counter-terrorism establishment in India including our intelligence
agencies do not seem to have penetrated the numerous terror support cells
which rely on misguided Muslim youth as foot soldiers of terror. Many
of these youngsters are motivated by money or the ideology of radical
Islam or both. Off late these homegrown operatives are being targeted
by the ISI which has an active recruitment campaign amongst section of
muslim community which has been radicalized. These youngsters only need
to be reminded about anti-Muslim violence in India and the riots in Gujarat.
Following the blasts, the police have been visiting
Muslim neighborhoods, picking up suspects and looking for clues. Since
most of these suspects are innocent and have nothing to do with terror
strikes, the result of such thoughtless action will be to generate further
resentment amongst the community members. This, in the long run, will
prove counter-productive. Without the cooperation and support of the muslim
community the majority of whom are law-abiding and patriotic, the security
establishment in India will hardly ever succeed in neutralizing terrorist
cells within the country.
In Pakistan, the initial tip off about the horrendous
plot to blow up several airliners came more than a year ago from an informant
belonging to the muslim community. Intercepted message from Pakistan to
Britain, the arrest of Rashid Rauf and an alert from an informant led
to the subsequent arrest of Rauf’s brother in Birmingham. The MI5
had infiltrated a bomb factory and found liquid explosives and detonators
weeks before they actually foiled the plot. The MI5 eavesdropped on the
suspect for weeks before arresting the suspects whose houses were bugged
after covert raids. The elaborate surveillance exercise enabled the MI5
to unearth the group’s plan, contacts and time of actual strike.
It has now been established that the Al-Qaeda cell which
plotted the strikes has operational links with terrorists operating in
Kashmir. Terrorism in Jammu and Kashmir, it has been proved again, is
an integral part of the global arc of Islamic terror. The role of Lashkar-e-Toiba
and several other Pakistan-based groups have once again come under sharp
international focus. The money provided by Jamaat-ud-Dawa (a charity front
of LeT) for earthquake relief in the POK is believed to have been used
to finance the plot. Several suspects have reportedly visited Pakistan
& attended training camps run by Tablighi Jamaat, an organization
used as recruiting base for Jehadis. A year ago, following terrorist attack
on London’s transportation system, Pakistan came under focus because
two suspects were found to have visited militant Islamic outfits in Pakistan.
This time Pakistan helped Britain in nabbing the suspects
and, as expected, Musharraf has received Kudos for his role in the global
war against terror. Nevertheless, the chain of events has proved conclusively
that Pakistan, the much touted ally of America in the war on terror, remains
a seedbed and primary source of Islamic terror. Khalid Muhammad Sheikh
(The Mastermind behind 9/11), Ramzi Yousef (Who carried out the attack
on WTC in 1993) and now Rashid Rauf (Key Player in the recent London blast)
all had Pakistan connection, one way or the other.
The British Police and the intelligence deserve credit
for painstaking work to prevent a mass casualty attack by terrorists the
like of which the world has yet to see. Within 24 hours, they released
the names and addresses of those arrested in sharp contrast to the performance
of Mumbai Police and our intelligence agencies. They had the photographs,
phone conversation intercepts, technical surveillance inputs, bank account
details of suspects which led to the U.S., Germany, Pakistan and several
other countries.
In the sixtieth year of its Independence, India’s
march to progress seems to depend largely on its ability and determination
to tackle the roots of terrorism nurtured in Pakistan and assisted by
Bangladesh. India has sent strong messages asking Pakistan to end cross-border
terrorism besides urging the international community to put pressure on
Pakistan. The Indian Prime Minister, is an unusually tough stand, has
announced on 15th August that the ‘Peace Process’ would not
progress unless Musharraf kept his (January 2004) pledge of not allowing
Pakistani territory for fomenting terrorism in India. The PM has said
“No one can make India kneel”. But firm and decisive action,
not tough words, is the need to the hour. India has displayed lamentable
lack of political will and courage to neutralize cross-border terrorism.
Musharraf will not dismantle his terror training camps or stop infiltration
across the LOC or through Bangladesh and Nepal unless India makes it really
costly for Pakistan to export terror. While the intelligence gathering
efforts are beefed up and the terrorist modules are neutralized, covert
operations against, selected targets across the border should be launched.
India has the capability. What it lacks is courage & the will to act.
It is unfortunate that our law enforcement agencies
and counter-terrorism outfits do not have a terrorism-specific law. The
ruling political elite in their mindless pursuit of political advantage
and vote bank have abolished the POTA whereas the US & the UK had
promptly passed the stringent Patriot’s Act & the Anti-Terror
Act respectively. India does not have a cogent policy for combating terrorism
yet. In the final analysis, the logic of overriding national interest
must prevail over petty short-sighted electoral interests. Harsh and unpopular
law’s have to be enacted, at least as temporary measure, to combat
terrorism. Bin Laden’s ‘International Islamic Front’
for Jihad against the crusaders, the Jews & the Hindus comprise Lashkar-e-Toiba,
Jaish-e-Mohammad, Harkat-ul-Mujahideen, Harkat-ul-Jihad-Islami, among
others. The India focused Jihad is no longer restricted to Kashmir. The
targets of Jehadi attack are now spread all over the country in its mass
transit systems, places of worship, shopping areas, cinema halls &
so on. The primary threat comes from LeT which, as the National Security
Advisor has reminded us, is the most visible manifestation of Al-Qaeda
& a part of the Al-Qaeda compact.
The terrifying spectre of the rise of radical Islam
is not only haunting the South Asian sub-continent, but most parts of
Europe today. This phenomenon is threatening, democratic secular multi-religious
nations which are especially vulnerable to this kind of terrorism. In
India, the fear of terrorist strikes in public places have turned the
daily lives of people upside down. The credibility of the security apparatus
of the state has been severely undermined. Earlier, it was a conflict
between the terrorists & the security forces. But it is no longer
so. Now it has touched the common people’s lives. The fear of the
bomb is a constant factor in day to day life of people. Hence, the sooner
the government acts to strike at the very root of terror, the better.
If our leaders fail to meet the challenge headlong, the people will have
no choice other than leaving in fear and waiting for the next blast. The
Prime Minister has assured the nation that we would win the war against
terrorism. But he has not said how that war will be won. Does he know
the answer? That is the question.
*Former Principal Director, DG Security
The views and facts stated above are entirely
the responsibility of the author and do not reflect the views of this
Association in any manner.
|